1

as the title stated, I would like to seek some ideas on the need of actually differentiating the choices. see below:

  • A: traditional checkboxes for multi-selects, radio button for single select
  • B: uses only checkboxes, perhaps with visual cues to inform user (see select state below)

default state

selected state

1
  • Checkboxes and radio buttons are proven concepts. Why would you break these concepts and try to fix them again with a non-proven concept? It only adds extra complexity for users, designers (otherwise you wouldn't have to ask this question) and developers.
    – jazZRo
    Nov 16, 2023 at 12:46

2 Answers 2

1

From your question, I cannot understand why your seek some ideas - do you have any indication that the established way of distinguishing single/multiple selection using checkbox/radiobutton does not work with your users, or for your use case?

In the absence of a (very) good reason to deviate from established practice, I'd always return to that established practice. A very good rationale is given in Jakob's Law in Internet Use.

0

Radio buttons are widely used and well understood, even on mobile design systems:

Using your alternative seems strictly worse: If I accidentally select option A and want to switch option B, I first have to understand I can't click B (it's greyed out), but have to uncheck A instead (which, given that everything else is greyed out, isn't entirely clear whether that's even possible), and only then can check B.

In stark contrast to this, with a radio button the user can just click option B and be done with it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.