Skip to main content
added 243 characters in body
Source Link
Bart Gijssens
  • 17.7k
  • 4
  • 50
  • 62

The "Browse..." button allows you to browse to a folder (using mouse input), whereas the edit box allows you to type in (or paste) a folder name (using keyboard input). Having the directory picker pop up as soon as you click the input box would cause 2 problems:

  • You cannot copy-paste folder names any more
  • You cannot type in folder names any more
  • Users don't expect that clicking an edit box pops up a dialog.

That's why you need a button and an edit box.

Ps.: I assume that with "directory picker", the following dialog is meant:

enter image description here

This dialog does not allow you to type in a folder name as others mention.

The "Browse..." button allows you to browse to a folder (using mouse input), whereas the edit box allows you to type in (or paste) a folder name (using keyboard input). Having the directory picker pop up as soon as you click the input box would cause 2 problems:

  • You cannot copy-paste folder names any more
  • You cannot type in folder names any more
  • Users don't expect that clicking an edit box pops up a dialog.

That's why you need a button and an edit box.

The "Browse..." button allows you to browse to a folder (using mouse input), whereas the edit box allows you to type in (or paste) a folder name (using keyboard input). Having the directory picker pop up as soon as you click the input box would cause 2 problems:

  • You cannot copy-paste folder names any more
  • You cannot type in folder names any more
  • Users don't expect that clicking an edit box pops up a dialog.

That's why you need a button and an edit box.

Ps.: I assume that with "directory picker", the following dialog is meant:

enter image description here

This dialog does not allow you to type in a folder name as others mention.

Source Link
Bart Gijssens
  • 17.7k
  • 4
  • 50
  • 62

The "Browse..." button allows you to browse to a folder (using mouse input), whereas the edit box allows you to type in (or paste) a folder name (using keyboard input). Having the directory picker pop up as soon as you click the input box would cause 2 problems:

  • You cannot copy-paste folder names any more
  • You cannot type in folder names any more
  • Users don't expect that clicking an edit box pops up a dialog.

That's why you need a button and an edit box.