You could add a Show All button ahead of the others and make that the default. When other filters are selected, it becomes deselected. W3Schools has a demo that might work well with a modification to allow more than one selection at a time.
There's a pattern for this type of UI: Filter chips
Material delineates the active filter state by adding a checkmark, and another click removes the checkmark:
you can also use an outline for more contrast:
Note: The better suggestion is below EDIT, but only if it is technically possible.
Since the extra button makes things overly complicated just omit it. You can add the "Close tab" option next to the "Create another" option:
Or add the options in a dropdown if this takes too much space.
In my opinion doing this only makes sense if closing ...