3

Is there any consensus as to whether users respond better to prompts phrased in the form of a question or in the form of a command? For instance:

"Which application would you like to run?"

vs.

"Please choose an application"

Or is it inconsequential?

1

While there isn't much research I could find upon this,

Asking a question doesn't necessary act as a prompt.

While I would definitely agree on using the question more if you were to speak with a Voice Assistant such as Google Now, SiRi or Cortana; in a Windows application with straightforward prompts such as Click here to Start, I think it's natural to go with the command.

It would be completely out of context to ask Would you like to click here to Start?

You are essentially encouraging the user to click on a particular application (assuming there isn't a default one or there couldn't be a compatible one that could be located), so using a command for a quick action by the user is appropriate. By using a question, you are basically having the user think about it for a couple of seconds longer before selecting.

As far as actions which have options one can select without the use of a Voice Assistant are concerned, I would definitely recommend to stick to the Command since it is straight forward, conveys what you need to do and does not have the user think a lot.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.