2

The application I'm working on performs very heavy calculations. Right now we're using an undeterminate spinner. I go nuts from this and can imagine our users get even more annoyed with it. I thought of having a determinate indicator, but we don't know how long the calculations will take.

So, I thought of providing a cancel button. Would this be a nice solution for the users and will it give them more control?

(when the application is calculating, there is nothing the user can do on the screen)

0

4 Answers 4

3

The left field answer to this is to make your calculation process asynchronous. In other words, don't trap your users on a page where you don't know how long they will be stuck. Instead, have the "submit" instance an asynchronous backround process, which will then notify the user once completed, at the end of the async process.

Basic user flow:

  1. submit request
  2. page says "your request is calculating, you will be notified, here are some other things you can be doing..."
  3. page instances an asynchronous process; in other words, the page submits merely a "calculate" request, and does not wait for the processing to complete
  4. Once calculations are complete, notify the user by push notification, email, ajax to the page, whatever fits your app stack

No more users sitting on a "dead" page.

The other thing to do would be to refactor your calculations so they are determinate and predictable in time period, which of course would require more time and regression testing. The async idea is, however, at least a significant step away from forcing the user to just sit there. :)

1

I'm not a fan of the cancel button as the only solution - would only encourage people to press it and probably would probably make them more impatient (don't think of a white elephant on a stool...dammit!). I'm assuming you have a warning about the length of time the calculations may take before they actually submit it (Warning - your calculations may take upwards of an hour (3 days, whatever). Don't close the window, but you may open a new window and gently browse while we chunk away for you.)

Can you run the calculation on a different page?

In terms of the underterminate indicator - are the calculations ordered at all (or can they be ordered?) You could display part of the calculation to the users so they know something is happening. Like installing software - thousands of libraries flash by, the user doesn't necessarily know what they do, but they know something is happening. If ordered, they may be able to ballpark about how much longer it would take.

1

I suggest you read a Technical Report from Carnegie Mellon's Software Engineering Insitute called "Supporting the CANCEL Command Through Software Architecture" that goes into a lot of the ins and outs about what to present to the user and how to implement it in software. There are also citations in the report to the research that supports the users' needs for a cancel in the situation you describe.

3
  • You might also find the following paper useful "The Value of a Usability-Supporting Architectural Pattern in Software Architecture Design: A Controlled Experiment". This paper is newer that the SEI TR and contains a complete list of the software responsibilities to consider when implementing a Cancel button (including all the issues people have brought up about blocking and warnings and other feedback). link. Aug 26, 2015 at 19:57
  • (Accidently poisted a duplicate comment -- can't seem to figure out how to remove it. Sorry) Aug 26, 2015 at 20:00
  • Hello Bonnie, there's a "delete" button at the right side of the comments, also, you're best to edit your answer and add the previous comments content instead of "commenting" :-) Also, if you're new to StackExchange, its best if you first take "the tour" - ux.stackexchange.com/tour
    – Xabre
    Aug 26, 2015 at 20:08
0

the first thing I was wondering was the fact that you mention that you can imagine that your users are more annoyed by it than you are, this seems like a perfect opportunity to go and figure that out, in the field :-)

I don't get why somebody would want to press the "cancel button", as there is, according to you, not much else they can do. There is some level of control added though, but to what purpose? I expect that one does the calculation, because that's his goal for that day.

Anyway, if the user could do anything else, you could consider putting it in a visual queue or something, so that the user may continue doing something else while he can check and see the progress of that calculation (in the upper corner for instance).

Something you should do, is warn the user that executing that action will take a very long time to calculate and that they won't be able to do anything else in the meanwhile.

You could also try to give an estimation of how long the calculation will probably run, and put the estimated countdown under the spinner. But in the end, it will always be more qualitative to figure out the time it will last. One thing you should than take into account, is the fact that it should simply move, eventhough it might be slow, some movement is better than none.

Sources:

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.