Mobile Sign up page


I have a very simple form to get users signed up. My MD (not the brand stakeholder) wants to use social sign-in as he thinks it's easier. I feel that because this is a small form, users are more inclined to complete it rather than being suspicious of handing over social access. He wants to add large social buttons top of the field (fb, G+ and Tw) but my argument is that due to this being mobile, it's going to push the form down and hide the Create Account button.

Has anyone had any experience as to what is more effective? My demographic is international 20-30 year olds.

PS prior to this form, the user has played some games and has won a prize, to claim the prize they must create an account.

Thanks in advance

  • users scroll and hiding things below the fold wont let people just say "Oh man, I HAVE to use my preferred social network?! leaves without scrolling - that situation rarely happens, especially with the target market you're talking about. Also on top of that, those buttons wont be so big to the point where nothing else is visible, at least that shouldn't be the case? – Majo0od Aug 5 '15 at 16:13

I hate filling out forms - most people hate filling out forms - and social connect provides an easy way for users to access a service.

I'm looking at the evidence out there and some folks say there is no difference using SC but others report higher signup rates using SC. So in most cases I would say provide both.


Text input on mobile is a nightmare.

Looking at your form, it aint that simple and is four fields to fill out, one of which is masked (the work of satan himself). So I'm never going to touch that form and I doubt the majority of your users will too.

My advice: move SC buttons top, limit form inputs to usr name, password (unmasked)

your boss is right

| improve this answer | |
  • +1 Agreed. There are few things worse for tech-heavy users these days than having to create yet another account with yet another password to remember. OAuth implementors also tend to implement much stronger security procedures - I mean, you are hashing passwords and encrypting all your stored user data, right....? – adelphus Aug 5 '15 at 18:27

The forms main focus is currently on signing up new users. Logging in for existing users is placed at the bottom which might let people create multiple accounts or quit because they've just entered two fields before realising they are signing up instead of logging in (personally hate this on Pinterest!). I would suggest making it more obvious for users that already have accounts.

That aside, MailChimp has a great article on the same issue you describe. http://blog.mailchimp.com/social-login-buttons-arent-worth-it/

Part of their conclusion was that people don't remember what service they used to log in, thus create multiple accounts or leave. And if they quit their social network you loose them as a user, and the user just lost his progress in your game!

My suggestion:

Remove the Social Logins, leave the Dob and Username fields for later on (you want people on board, so ask as little as possible). Now that you only have two fields left, you can use those same fields for new users and users with accounts. So no confusion for them anymore. Wether it should be one button or two (login / sign up) depends on your design and copy.

| improve this answer | |

Make the login buttons of each type similar looking to show they're all equally valid. Currently the social ones are relegated to mere text links.

enter image description here

| improve this answer | |
  • this is all wrong. Look at your two calls to action sign in and sign up! Sign up is red which makes me think its a warning! – colmcq Aug 6 '15 at 10:45
  • It's red because OP used a red button. I didn't really change the methods, just the relative importance of them. – PixelSnader Aug 6 '15 at 10:50
  • i think op had a few things wrong and its up to us lot to fix – colmcq Aug 6 '15 at 12:09
  • The button is red due to strict brand guidelines and DOB capture is a requirement form the client – spacewood Aug 7 '15 at 14:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.