I've been asked to remove a legal disclaimer and "by clicking yes you accept...", from the bottom of a competition form.

The suggestion has been to put all this information into a pop-up when clicking submit, at which point the user will then click accept or do not accept to submit the form.

My initial thoughts on a pop-up are NO WAY. We are adding an extra action and highlighting a reason to decline. and pop-ups.. ugh.

Any suggestions on a good solution? What is best practice? Thanks

  • Instead of popping up another window, why not do an on-page modal popup? The nomenclature eludes me, but demo.web3designs.com/… shows a simple example when you click "Sign Up" or "Login". The underlying architecture is CSS and there is a good description (linked at the bottom of page).
    – polarysekt
    Commented Jun 17, 2015 at 1:09

1 Answer 1


It's OK to use a popup here

Assuming you need positive user affirmation of the legal disclaimer (ie it's important to you that the user directly clicks to affirm the legal content), a modal pop-up is not only fine but it has several benefits:

  • The pop-up channels user focus onto the legal content (assuming you are masking or otherwise de-emphasizing the background). So lawyers feel comfortable that the user has been given a clear and unambiguous opportunity to read the content.

  • It provides clear choices to the user. The blocking pop-up interaction with agree/cancel provides helps frame and force a clear choice for the user in a way that doesn't make the user not feel trapped (she can exit the dialog and cancel).

  • It takes advantage of behavioral sunk cost. By sequencing the disclaimer after the Submit button, you are reducing the up-front friction for completing the form. By the time the user sees the disclaimer dialog, he has already invested time completing the form and pressing Submit, so he is more likely to accept the legal terms, because he's already invested in the completion process.

    • I forget the exact name of this behavioral principle (anyone?) but it's the same principle that causes people to buy an item even after discovering that there is a sales or service tax on top of the expected price...they have already invested cognitively in making the purchase so they're likely to accept the incremental cost to finish the transaction.
    • Not all designers would be comfortable with the moral position of this approach, but if you are not keeping the user's details if she doesn't consent perhaps you can feel comfortable, but in any case you should pause to give appropriate thought to the moral pros and cons here.

If you decide to do this...

I would recommend using animations, transitions, color palette, fonts, and layout to make the pop-up interaction as smooth and harmonious as possible.

This will present the interface in a way that makes the added cognitive disruption and decision cost of the disclaimer as low-friction as possible.

A good functional example to think about for inspiration is to look at how pharmaceutical companies read out their legal disclaimers during drug TV ads. They use a calm color palette, soothing voice, and smooth, flowing and happy visuals to help calm and even distract users from the difficult content of the legal disclaimer.

  • For example, see this ad for Lunesta. Most of the airtime is actually devoted to the legal disclaimer, but the smooth design allows the legal language to feel less painful.
  • Again, it's up to you to consider the moral issues here, I am only pointing out the technical design considerations.

By the way, legal departments are where good UX goes to die....

  • 1
    Thank you @tohster that is exactly what I was looking for! We are going to look at a easy lightbox so it is not too disruptive with simple text and cta. Your point on behavioural sunk cost makes a lot of sense - thank you. and lol @ legal departments. too true! Commented Jun 17, 2015 at 2:57
  • "By submitting this form, you agree..." can work fine, but according to an attorney who spoke at NJ Tech Meetup on this, it's not legally as strong as a user actively indicating that they agree to terms. Commented Jun 17, 2015 at 14:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.