3

Question:
In a 'Create new' wizard, what is a good way to create sub-object?

I will have a wizard to create an object, Item.
An Item will always belong to another object, Group.
A Group will in itself belong to yet another object, Container.

The Group and Container are simple objects with just a Name and Description. But the Item is the main object and is more complex. It will probably require multiple Wizard pages.

Now I need to create a wizard to create this item, including a Group if not using one already existing. Example screenshot:

Example of wizard

These are the alternatives that I've been considering. None of them seem desirable to me.

Alternative 1:
Instead of the "Create new group" option in the drop-down, add a link to open a "Create new Group" dialog popup window on top of the wizard.
This dialog would in itself have a "Create new Container" link that would pop up a "Create new Container" dialog on top.

Alternative 2:
Like the screenshot, creating a new Group will simply be a choice in a drop-down. Making this choice will take you to Step 2 of the wizard once you click Next step, otherwise skipping directly to Step 4.
The same method is used in Step 2 where you select container.

Alternative 3:
If selecting Create new group in the drop-down, new option will appear below with a slide animation, containing Group name, Group desc, and Group container. If Create new container is selected, yet another slide animation will reveal Container name and Container desc.

2

I myself like a pop-up in this situation.

enter image description here Leads to this pop-up...

enter image description here Note, I place "Create new group" lastly in dropdown list. Now the trick is to add yet another pop-up for the New Container. It should be no problem to have the three panels open at once.
You could use an expanding pop-up to reduce clutter.

enter image description here Expands to...

enter image description here Good luck!

  • 1
    Thanks for the input! Yes, I guess in a way having three dialog panels could be handled, but I find it looking a bit 'unprofessional' somehow. But your suggested combination of Alt1 (for Group) and Alt3 (for Container) could work out well. I'll try it! – ANisus May 13 '15 at 9:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.