5

Do you think it is a good or bad idea, and why? Also, why do you think Comedy Central (e.g., The Daily Show) put their play button in the top-left corner instead of the middle?

enter image description here

  • 2
    Is it truly the play button, or just an icon that represents what will happen when you click anywhere in the video? – Evil Closet Monkey May 14 '14 at 13:00
  • 1
    @EvilClosetMonkey The fact that you're not sure is sign enough that something not-right is going on. – Racheet May 14 '14 at 13:01
  • 1
    @Racheet, that depends on the goal of the original question. Many "play" buttons that appear transposed over the video aren't really buttons - clicking anywhere in the video plays (or pauses). The fact that this is up in the corner doesn't immediately imply a "not-right" situation. – Evil Closet Monkey May 14 '14 at 13:05
  • 4
    This question is asking for pure speculation and therefore is not a good fit for a Q&A site such as this. – Code Maverick May 14 '14 at 13:26
  • 1
    The real question, why THEY did it can only be asnwered by themselves. The question if this is a good idea is something else. – Bart Gijssens May 14 '14 at 13:32
6

When looking at an image, the user tends to start from the center as it's the main focus point. I would opt to put the play button in the middle to ensure that the user knows its not a picture and it is a video. By putting the play button at the bottom the user may think its a picture.

Youtube (which one would argue is the most well known online video site) puts the play button in the middle, so one would assume that most users would be expecting this.

2

It depends on the context. If you've started watching the content, and then pause, the play button should be centered, and the video image could be darkened to show it's inactive.

I tried taking a look at the site, but as I'm European it won't let me see the actual video. What I did see though, was a bunch of thumbnails/links. And in those cases, yeah, I understand they moved the arrow. Compare their solution with a mockup of centered triangle:

enter image description here

In half the cases the triangle covers up a face. 75%, if we count Batman. That both makes the face unrecognizable, and it makes the triangle harder to read clearly. By moving the icon to a corner, you have much less interference between the focal point of the video/shot, and the triangle indicator.

The same logic would apply to a large video (before watching). Moving the triangle keeps the center of the image clean, which makes for a much nicer looking page. And if they do keep the triangle in the corner as play/pause indicator, that's for internal consistency.

As for why the top-left corner; western cultures read left-to-right and top-to-bottom, so it's the first corner we look at.

As a sidenote; have you ever paid close attention to YouTube? On search pages and channel listings the triangle isn't anywhere to be found. It's only on actual videos. YouTube doesn't need the triangle to signify that something's a video, because it's a video site.

This site doesn't quite have the same affordance (all content on this site is video) but it has a similar affordance; the daily show is a TV/video show.

In short:

  • the triangle should not be the button (the whole screen should be a big play/pause button)
  • moving the triangle makes the frame/site look better
  • moving the triangle makes the triangle stand out more.
  • this site has less need to point out that a video is a video as it's the main content type

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.