I have a page for a doctor's practice. In the summary page for the practice there is a list of subsections. Some of these sub sections are very large, others can be a paragraph or 2 with a short unordered list.

The large subsections warrant their own separate page, the smallers one's not so much. I created a little plugin which enables me to use the list of subsections in 2 ways. When clicking on the title of a larger section, you'll be sent through to it's own page. For the smaller sections, a slide down box will open with the information.

When clicking on these titles, should it be consistent so that the user always knows that clicking on a title means either going to a new page OR getting slide down content? Or is it ok to mix both?

The titles don't look like hyperlinks, they've been styled as thick horizontal bars.

1 Answer 1


It would be better to make it consistent for all the titles. You are basically making it a battle for the user to 'guess' what clicking a particular title will do; will it open a new page OR will it open a box?

  • You can create a long page with all the titles are sections and have a navigation at the top where clicking on a title will scroll you to its position (have a back to top link in each section)

  • You can have a module/window slide open like an accordion when you click a title, so all the titles have their description open in place and you get everything on a single page.

  • You can visually treat the smaller sections separately. Create a side-bar with content of all the small pages and use the center space to link all the independent pages or so.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.