2

In Internet Explorer 11 the file download dialog appears at the bottom of the window. I know many people who don't know where to find the "save" and "open" buttons after having clicked on a download link on a website.

It seems to me that the small yellow stripe does not attract enough attention. enter image description here

Is there any reason to put the dialog at the bottom? To me it looks more like a notification bar than a "proper" dialog box.

5

Downloading a file really doesn't need to be an obstructive action, so they've ditched the old dialog box. The old version was pretty obtrusive even though immediate action isn't strictly required:

enter image description here

Really you only need to take action after the file is downloaded, there's no pressure. Particularly when downloading multiple files, the old IE's dialog got very annoying very quickly. In fact it's still much more annoying than Firefox and Chrome's download system, which implicitly assumes you want to save files you download.

Chrome's download bar follows a similar path of least obstruction:

enter image description here

Here they've made a dropdown to use secondary actions and the file is "saved" by default (Firefox does this as well). I'm surprised IE didn't go this way, but they seem to have wanted to keep "cancel" an easily accessible option (it used to be the default action in fact), almost certainly for security reasons due to the notice IE8 gives you.

Windows' use of modal dialog boxes has drastically decreased since their "peak" which was probably around windows 95/98. Modal dialogs are quite disruptive so eliminating them when unnecessary is certainly a good design goal. The notification bar might be less noticeable the first time, but this is a browser; you quickly learn how common features act, and it's likely to be one of your most used applications, so ease of use long-term is preferable over help so in-your-face it gets annoying.

It looks like you're downloading a file. Would you like help?

1

Despite what most people think, IE has not "ditched" or "gotten rid of" the dialog box, or at least not for file download anyway. What they've done is use the notification bar as default, but there is a way to change that and use the dialog box again in the newer IE versions. I know because I have some users that see the dialog box and some that see the notification bar when downloading the same file, and everyone has IE11.

Now, if I could just find that setting... Does anybody know what setting it would be?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.