Two search bars on the same page or combination?

Question

The main use of my site is video browsing. There is a search bar in the nav to search for videos. My site also has a photo section. I need to add search functionality on the photo section. I'm torn between:

1. Having 2 search bars. The one in the nav for videos and one towards the top when browsing the photo sections.
2. When browsing the photo section, the nav search bar only searches photos. (Don't think this is a good idea..)
3. A multiple select search.. So a dropdown next to the search bar that lets users toggle between video and photo search. When browsing photos the default selected is photos.

Answer 1

I vote for option #4.

A search from the main page should show mostly videos and a few pictures to hint to the user that there may be more content types on the site than they realize.

If they're searching from a picture page, show mostly pictures but a few related videos as well.

^{download bmml source – Wireframes created with Balsamiq Mockups}

Answer 2

I really think that these day's (in the tablet era) people are really used to the combined box it also spares space on your UI and the more uncluttered Ui you have, the better.

Here is a way how you can do this. Hope this helps.

Answer 3

In addition to Karen's mockup, the search box could look like the mockup below. This will allow the user to choose what they are searching for without any extra steps to get the search results. If they don't choose whether they want Photos or Videos, Karen's solution would fit. Ultimately, functioning like Google Instant Search.

The first Search box is the default search box. The second one is an example of what a search would look like. Options to search for photos/videos are made available in the drop down, which is activated when the cursor is detected in the search field.

Answer 4

There has been testing done for this, and there should never be more than one search box for content. Scoped searches can be useful, as long as you provide clear feedback on the scope being searched in the box and on the results; drcyrus3d's example looks like it does this well. However, users do not consider an address book 'content', so you may want a separate search box for the photo search if it feels like a search for a user, not a search for content. This may require some testing to see how your user base perceives this search type.

Answer 5

Why not have a single search bar and make the back-end search across both?

Dual search bars is not recommended.

Answer 6

What no text? Really? Not captions, not abstracts, not even taxonomy?

You could have one search box with four radio buttons: text, videos, pictures, everything.

As a lay user, esp. on my first few visits, I would be happy to see something like that to help me.

Having different functionalities on different pages may be intuitive-responsive in design, but is disruptive as well and the user could make unintentional mistakes.