0

It's about a desktop app in which users can open a modal containing a list of items. Some of these items may have one type of action associated with them.

Does it make sense to make the entire item clickable while also retaining the button?

enter image description here

1
  • Is this web content? Because, besides that it's fine to do from UX perspective, the technical implementation can be a bit hard from accessibility point of view. Be aware that the button should be technically outside the clickable area and has to be styled so that it is visually inside.
    – jazZRo
    Commented Mar 27 at 12:50

2 Answers 2

0

Yep, definitely. It's totally fine to keep the whole row clickable while also keeping the button in some cases. Why?

  1. Keeping the whole item clickable it makes it easier for users to click it. It's bigger, mistake/off mouse friendly, you can reach the goal faster
  2. Otherwise you would need to make item name clickable, which requires the user to be slower, more precised.
  3. Especially if you don't have the button in all the rows, it's just more friendly to keep the whole item clickable, similar reason to point 1.

Just make sure the button is easy to click, has hover state so you can distinguish when you hover over button and when over the row only:)

0

Having a clickable list item, with a clickable button that performs the same action is mostly an intuitive behaviour. Users will intuit the button designates an action, and even if they don't intuit that the highlight means the whole tile is clickable they're be able to perform the action.

However, having a list of clickable items and non-clickable items together could cause confusion. Will the Items w/o actions not highlight on hover? Will users understand the difference between rows which do/don't highlight? Will the clickable tile offer any value not already met by the button?

I'm super curious about the overall use case here. What is this modal presenting?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.