The primary goal is to have them repurchase. Can you drop the other asks of them?
Don't distract them from the purchase process.
So you have 2 things you're asking of the customer here, all while you're getting them to do the main thing: hit that BUY AGAIN button.
The first (thumbs up, thumbs down) seems unnecessary because if they like the wine, they'd just buy it again.
The second (tasting notes) is really for your company to sell more wine by building up some kind of (recommendation engine?). Could you do that after the purchase in some way?
The main thing is to separate the purchase process from the review process. Even from just a graphic design perspective, the Tasting Notes bar is bigger than the BUY AGAIN button. They don't need to live together.
If you must have them together, try putting the review subordinate to any purchase call-to-action, or near the purchase history. They can follow the link to leave a review.
- You might also try to deemphasize the 'Complete' green. Since the purchase was completed, do you need to have this here? At the very least you can lessen the emphasis
- Try making the CTA button more noticeable. I know it's the brand color, but perhaps it can stand out more. Right now the 50% off and the Complete lozenge are more colorful.
