0

Imagine a simple messenger app. Where to place the first message(s) in a chat? See examples below.

A or B in a messenger

E.g. Slack, Facebook's Messenger does it the A way. Snapchat, WhatsApp does it the B way.

I'd argue the B way is more correct due to F reading pattern, however, can someone shed me some light on this?

3

It might be related to bottom/top posting. If users are conditioned to look above the text input for the latest response, aligning to the bottom (example A) would make it more consistent.

If 95% of a user's chats have enough messages in them to scroll, then it might be weird to start a new chat and see the first few messages aligned to the top (example B).

I don't think it's a big deal either way, there doesn't seem to be any standardization on this yet.

1
  • 1
    +1 For "not a big deal". Both methods are usable. – PhillipW Mar 31 at 8:19
2

F-shaped reading pattern is observed in text scanning applied when reading regular web-content like pages or articles.

For chat and messaging applications the timeline of posts may follow a different flow (see top- snd bottom-posting).

So the scan for new posts pattern applied by users might also expect the newly typed message to directly bubble up like a balloon above the text input field. This would also mean a shorter distance for the eyes. Reading starts at the input field (bottom) and after submission the focus moves slightly atop to the last recently posted message.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.