3

Our testing web application currently displays inner component scrolling when the question's body exceeds a specific size (to prevent browser scrolling).

Should we allow the content to be stretched, thus delegating scrolling to the browser?

To emphasize, we have a test application where candidates should review the question's content in the most convenient way.

The following images are attached; with inner component scroll and with browser scroll

inner component scroll

browser scroll

Highly appreciate your thoughts,

6

The way I see it, these are the main arguments here:

Nested Scrolling

  • Pro: More order, everything stays in place, user knows fixed location of all elements
  • Contra: User's working area is limited, browser search may not work correctly

Browser Scrolling

  • Contra: Elements may be displaced, depending on how it is implemented (is answer section sticky on the right and is always visible or is it fixed on top and disappears on scroll)
  • Pro: Working area is completely free, text scanning is enhanced through easy search in browser

I imagine in a scenario with a limited time frame the user's focus is to work through the given text content as clearly and quickly as possible. Because of this I also imagine the browser search might become an often used tool while looking for specific phrases in a long text.

Overall, the 'feeling' of working with the text can quickly become 'limited' in a nested scroll environment, as you have the impression of not having full control over the content, but having to cherrypick it from the container. On the other hand, having it be displayed fully feels more like a long piece of paper lying in front of you, where you make mental remarks of where important phrases may be.

Because of this I feel like the browser stretched scrolling is the better option here. But it is equally important to always have the answer possibilities in mind, which is why the answer container should definitely remain sticky & visible at all times. Example below.

An example showing sticky scrolling components

This all is based on the assumption that the content is very important, of course. If it's not, the two options aren't really that dramatically different.

  • 1
    Adding to this answer: there are other Use Cases for web browsers to consider: printing, screenshots, quality assurance tools, screen readers, etc. Consider what you break or make harder by using nested scrolling and whether that is good or bad for your business and Users. – straya Jan 29 at 1:50
1

I prefer web scrolling than inner scrolling. At first we think about user experience, inner scrolling present a better view but most of time user skip content in inner scrolling section.

  • Thanks for contributing to UXSE! To help improve the answer that you have provided, consider providing some examples or references to support why you believe web scrolling works better for the scenario outlined in the question. – Michael Lai Jan 29 at 5:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.