2

What are the pros and cons of placing controls in menu bars? This is an example from a Linux desktop environment:

enter image description here

enter image description here

I've personally found the placement of the controls in the title bar unexpected, after ~20+ years of Windows/Linux/web usage. Is this style common somewhere? I'd like to learn more about guidance in this area.

5
  • Are you trying to find a way to tell someone else they're doing it wrong?
    – Confused
    Dec 15 '18 at 22:38
  • 2
    @Confused: if there are better ways of doing it than this, I'd like to have a more informed opinion on what those ways are. Dec 15 '18 at 23:26
  • The first screens a bit of a muddle: where do you type in your search term ?
    – PhillipW
    May 10 at 13:02
  • @PhillipW that's the settings for search, i.e. what items are included in the standard desktop-wide search.
    – lights0123
    May 10 at 14:35
  • Thanks for clarifying.
    – PhillipW
    May 10 at 17:15
0

I believe that this is one particular approach to creating a consistent look & feel across both mobile and desktop applications.

There are of course other approaches you can take as well (such as creating customized mobile and desktop interfaces), but there isn't really a right or wrong approach because it is based on the history of the application and user preferences.

Toggles behave in a very similar way to radio buttons in that there is generally a two-state selection and that it needs to be in one state or another (sometimes there is also support for an indeterminate state), but are more compact and can also be clearer if the labels are applied correctly. But it is generally not suitable when more than two states are possible.

0

Toggles are usually placed in title bars (read headers) in scenarios where you have a singular global control to be manipulated.

Global toggle controls can come in handy if there is a significant probability that the singular control would be frequently required and accessed by the user, or in case the complete application shares the singular control.

This is afforded by the Law of Common Region as the toggle is usually grouped with other global controls such as search and navigation, and would naturally imply to the user that the changes would be applied globally.

Example scenario where a user might need global singular control

If a user can play multiple roles on a platform simultaneously where one role affords the user significant privilege over the other, say an admin who can also double up as an end user on the platform, the global toggle can be used to mitigate any risks of accidental alterations by the higher privilege role.

Mac does this within certain preference menu items, such as Security & Privacy under System Preferences, via the Lock icon that can be toggled to unlock administrative privileges across all the tabs within Security & Privacy.

Click the lock to unlock administrative privileges on Mac

Click the lock to prevent further changes on Mac

Example scenario where the application shares the singular control

The dark mode toggle on Google Fonts and many other websites that afford the user to update the language and visual preference to suit their needs is set on the header to bring them to the user's attention at short notice and their clubbing with the global options naturally implies that the changes would be applicable globally.

Dark Mode toggle on Google Fonts

Having said that, it's also very easy to overuse the global toggles leading to a cluttered interface with barely any cognisance of purpose. Hence, it's highly recommended that you extensively debate over the need of a global toggle—of the lack of it—before choosing to incorporate one.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.