2

This is a multiple-part question:

  1. Why is it common to see the j and k keys implemented respectively as forward and backward navigation in web apps? I think it because of Bill Joy's work on vi and the choices made by the interface designers of the ADM-3A terminal.

  2. More importantly, why is j associated with forward while k is associated with back? It seems counter-intuitive to me as someone who primarily reads and writes left-to-right, top-to-bottom. If my thoughts are correct about #1, I want to understand in a detailed way why the original designers chose these associations.

I am looking for authoritative information to support answers.

Here is an example: a screenshot of a portion of the keyboard shortcuts available at https://music.youtube.com:

enter image description here

6

1) The choice of j and k is indeed inherited from the ADM-3A terminal by way of vi (source). vi is a popular enough editor among Google engineers that j, k and a few other shortcuts inspired from it (for example / for search, y for yank) took root in Gmail and then YouTube (source on popularity of vim at Google).

2) To understand where this design came from, especially the choice of J for "down" rather than K, a relevant document is the ASCII standard established in 1963. On page 5 of that standard, we can already see that the character corresponding to binary "0001010" (hex 0x0A) is line-feed control character (marked "LF"), and the character corresponding to binary "1001010" (hex 0x4A) is J.

In many computers, even to this day, the effect of the Ctrl key is to input a character with code 0x40 less than the code of the character that would otherwise be typed, so that Ctrl+J would have resulted in a line-feed when sent to a printer (meaning that the paper would have rolled to the next line under the print head) and, by analogy, moving the cursor to the next line when sent to a display terminal.

In 1967 Ctrl+H (control character with hex code 0x08, since H is character with hex code 0x48) acquired the meaning of backspace ("BS") in the revised ASCII standard; it was previously "format effector" (FE0). We now understand backspace to mean the deletion of the previous character on screen, but back on the days of printing terminals, the role of backspace was to move the print head backwards one character to allow printing accents (so for example the sequence E backspace ’ would print something like É). It's a natural fit for .

The choice of the other keys doesn't map as clearly to the ASCII spec, for example Ctrl+K was "vertical tabulation" (VT), Ctrl+K was "form feed" (FF), but H and J were pretty much already assigned to backspace and linefeed, respectively, so that by the time the ADM-3A came out in 1976 it made sense to map them to and . respectively. The choice of then using K and L for and , which might have been novel to the ADM-3A, seems to result from a simple desire to lay out the cursor keys symmetrically.

|improve this answer|||||
  • Hi. Thanks for taking time to respond to my question. I realized that I might not have been explicitly clear about the second question, so I edited my question. I am looking for information about why the original designers chose those associations. – jsejcksn Jul 4 '18 at 3:16
  • @jsejcksn thanks, updated the reply with more authoritative information. – qoba Jul 4 '18 at 4:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.