1

Using material design and making a desktop application.

Should I add the delete and edit button on each row like this:

1

or in the Color zone at the right (near the 3 dots):

2

1

Why not like this? enter image description here

The ability to specific items is arguably better because of the shorter mouse movement and its easy to understand what's being edited.

But it depends, should a user be able to edit multiple items?

  • Hi, I edited this for clarity and removed the language about "preference". Objective answers shouldn't make reference to what you like or what you prefer. An option is either better or not, or it's at least possible to argue for it being better. Likes and preferences shouldn't be a factor. – dennislees Aug 28 '18 at 17:14
  • Also, the type of clarifying question you ask at the end is the kind of thing that should be a comment under the main question. You can end up wasting your time by working on a question turns out to be based on a wrong assumption that you could have easily clarified first. Provide your answer when you have no further questions of your own. – dennislees Aug 28 '18 at 17:15
0

It depends! ( I love giving that answer...not such a fan of receiving it. )

To expand.... as rhauger mentions above "should a user be able to edit multiple items?" I like that question and would add another consideration. How often is a user deleting rows? Is deleting a primary action? If so, the button should be promoted to the left side. If it it is a seldom used action, then demote it to the end. Same for "edit" functions. Depending on the frequency of use...

This is based on the "Path To Completion: strategy from Nielsen Norman described here....

https://www.nngroup.com/articles/web-form-design/

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.