1

I noticed that clicking the "Download" option/button in Google Drive, Slack, etc. doesn't prompt the user for where they want to save, and with what filename. It just goes to my "Downloads" folder with a default name. Is that standard?

  • Are you talking about web-app in a browser or a native app (phone or PC)? Because, as far as I'm aware, in a browser, it's not the app's choice whether to show a Save As or just store it in a standard location. (Chrome lets the user choose whether to always ask or not; in IE it is harder). Personally, I like to choose (but accept many people don't) so if it is a native app, I'd give people the choice like Chrome does. – TripeHound May 14 '18 at 11:14
0

Yes, that's standard. The filename will be whatever the host site named it.

There may be situations that call for a different experience (as another answer suggested) but if the question is whether or not it's standard practice to use the given filename at download then I would say the answer is yes.

The only possible exception I can think of is downloading a PDF from an online PDF viewer. You may get a full save dialog box in some cases.

1

I would make the choice based on user expectations. Most browsers default to downloading content to the "Downloads" folder hence you can be fairly confident that users will be familiar with this construct and will know where to look to find their files. With other applications e.g. a business app with sensitive information, this may not be the best choice so you would likely want to prompt the user for the download destination

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.