2

I can start with simple example,

User 'A' have to play multiple roles such as Manager, Team leader, and developer under the single sign in. By default, I am a manager when I am logging in, but I should be able to switch my role to team leader role and see the respective content with very minimal click.

I would suggest going with tab UI to switch role option rather than having drop-down at the right top corner such as Gmail account switch option. Is this efficient way of approach or any UX flaws in it? Any suggestions?

  • 1
    How different is each UI from the others? Is it mostly the same UI, but with some features exposed/hidden depending, or is each quite different? – dennislees Feb 28 '18 at 20:06
  • In terms of UI, there is no much difference. Having said that, 90% - 95% of user interface is very similar for all roles, but with different contents based on access permissions and user journey. – Vasethvan Mar 1 '18 at 4:46
  • What are your concerns about the dropdown? – dennislees Mar 1 '18 at 5:00
1

Besides it's hard to evaluate the difference other than seeing them online, dropdown and tab identation seem both good solutions. Hence, I would reccomend giving Roles as a seperate Navigation (if it's possible & on top preferably) with the roles listed when on hover (other then direct dropdown) to be able to give user the sense of account change rather than waiting him/her to check other tabs under his/her control.

By this way it's user's responsibility to check and see everything presented under the role. Otherwise there might be missing scope by some of the users not aware of the using this platform I suppose (experience from a couple of similar uses cases).

1

I'd like to point out an whole other approach to the problem. One Person has multiple roles, the question is, if this person actually slips in different roles during the usage of the application or does the user just have multiple roles that are changed fluidly during the usage. I assume that a user is e.g. manager AND teamleader during the whole day and not manager in the morning and teamleader in the afternoon.

Said so, my suggestion would be not to change roles but to show all the information the user has access to according to the different roles. So the user has to deal with only one UI. All needed information/functions are always shown so the user does not have to deal with the (from users point of view abstract) roles.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.