2

My organization has tasked me with copying a specific stacked bar chart (someone stumbled upon it on the web) in order to visually display information about 100 Year Lifecycle Investment Requirements.

The chart looks like this (it can also be found on page '"v" of this document):


enter image description here


I'm not a data visualization expert by any stretch of the imagination, but I find myself being awfully critical of this stacked bar chart. Mainly, I find it incredibly difficult to glean meaning from it.

The chart is attempting to communicate several stacked values over time:

  • Maintenance
  • Renewal/Rehabilitation
  • Replacement Expansion
  • Disposal
  • Non-Infrastructure
  • Backlog

But if you asked me to describe what the data actually means, I'd say: "well, I dunno, things seem to be going up over time". But other than that, even with the statistics in the top left corner, it doesn't seem to tell a simple enough story.

Given the subject matter, is a stacked bar chart the best way to display the data? Or are there other industry standards/options that might be suitable alternatives?

  • Can you elaborate the story you want the data to show? That can help to determine some alternative visualizations. – Mike M Jan 5 '18 at 1:52
3

I think a stacked bar chart with this many values over such a long period of time is indeed not easy for readers to understand. Think about what is the message you're trying to convey with showing the graph. A graph visualization should have a message it's trying to tell to it's readers. Currently the graph has so many stories in one visualization that it's hard to grasp for readers.

I would suggest one of the following options, depending on your goal:

  1. Separate bar charts for the values (one for maintenance, one for disposal, etc.). This way you show the increase, decrease in these values overtime.

  2. Decrease the number of timestamps you're comparing. For example instead of 100 bars, 4 pie charts to show the change in ratio between the values maintenance, disposal, etc...

  3. Same bar graph you currently have, without the stacks, just the total number.

1

Consider the technique of breaking up larger and more complex blocks of information into more manageable chunks, especially if you want to untangle the difficulty of visualizing and understanding this type of information.

Instead of a stacked chart you can easily plot multiple charts over the same axis, or create 'small multiples' which is basically creating smaller versions of single charts and grouping them for easier comparison.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.