I'd like to know what you think about these two solutions. We're working on a big portal, where FAQ is gonna be really important section.

We're arguing about two versions - the difference is in "FAQ Detail" - in one version you can see more questions of specific category right under the category title in left side-menu, in the other one there are links on the bottom of the question.

It is probable that lot of users come through Google right onto the FAQ detail, so it's gonna be first page they see.

Sorry, had to remove the content, hope it'll be enough to catch the idea.

Won't write my preferred version, don't wanna influence you :)


Thanks a lot!

  • The menu option doesn't seem to allow for scalability. Could there be dozens of questions? You'd likely not want all of those being listed on the side menu. – Tory Oct 4 '16 at 20:22
  • I don't see any (relevant) difference between V1 and V2 on axshare. – virtualnobi Oct 5 '16 at 7:12

At a glance, both examples produce a really high cognitive load. Users typically go one of two paths when considering the use of a FAQ. Either they have a very common question or a relatively unique question. Forcing a user to scan all questions is a bit overwhelming - and less technically adept users don't utilize the browser search function as much as you'd like.

As Tory called out as well, you also need to factor in scalability. FAQs should be viewed as a living area - constantly growing. You won't know what kinds of questions people will start to ask until they start using it. And as you add more features/functionality those questions will continue to grow.

A new pattern that's been established to handle this is to identify the most common questions and make them easily accessible. All other questions can be handled by a search function, preferably with a combo box that supports type-ahead.

enter image description here

This allows for the majority of users with common questions to be satisfied immediately without overwhelming them with a lot of choices. It also allows users with unique questions to get what they need as well. Users with unique questions typically have an issue framing their question so the type-ahead combo box helps them with that.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.