4,567 reputation
3923
bio website wovenreed.com
location United Kingdom
age 33
visits member for 1 year, 7 months
seen yesterday

me


1d
comment Offline mode and possible sync issues
@Macks, I agree that something along those lines is another potential solution. The key is making whatever limitation you impose clear ahead of time.
2d
answered Offline mode and possible sync issues
Nov
15
comment Is there any justification for different behavior of different ways of triggering the same action?
@Bluewater, I don't understand how any of those rules should not apply in some cases because "people evolve". Can you give an example?
Nov
14
awarded  Enlightened
Nov
13
awarded  Benefactor
Nov
13
comment Is there any justification for different behavior of different ways of triggering the same action?
I'm not sure customizing the behavior for different users is really what I'm talking about. That doesn't strike me as an "inconsistent" behavior.
Nov
13
comment Is there any justification for different behavior of different ways of triggering the same action?
Thanks, there were several good answers here, but I think yours had the best balance of pros and cons, while actually addressing the examples I raised.
Nov
12
awarded  Student
Nov
11
awarded  Promoter
Nov
10
comment (How) does capitalization affect readability
Interesting; I wonder if there is any research on this. I think conventions like title case exist as ways to identify different types of content when only one typeface was available (e.g. documents created on typewriters). These days, there are many other ways to stylistically signal that something is a title.
Nov
9
comment How to cope with a “UX Expert” who has no experience?
@Crissov, the assumption that the UX guy is right and the developers don't "get it" isn't warranted. The OP offers significant evidence that his UX skills really are lacking: no testing/research, not valuing simplicity and functionality, not understanding requirements, no working knowledge of basic implementation issues, not being happy with how his own design works when implemented, not being able to effectively communicate and work with a development team. UX people are used to having good advice ignored, but that doesn't mean it is true in every case.
Nov
9
comment Do material design's floating action buttons provide a bad UX?
Do left-handed people tend to hold the device in their left hand? I would think they would hold it with their right, so that they can use their other hand for navigation. I am right-handed, and I always hold my phone with my left. This is true even when performing one-handed actions, because I am used to having it in that hand, and it feels unnatural to hold it with my right.
Nov
9
comment Do material design's floating action buttons provide a bad UX?
Why is this a problem? The user still gets visual feedback that the button was pressed, and I don't see what confusion this could cause. A visual appearance "contrary to what the user is accustomed to" only matters if there are consequences.
Nov
8
comment Similar buttons for very different actions in Gmail
Missing from this answer is consideration of whether GMail's decision is actually a problem. I have never confused the two. It seems to me that the location of the buttons provides context that removes any ambiguity. (Of course, maybe I am just used to it as a long time user. But it's not obvious that this is actually a problem. I think that needs to be established with evidence. And the assumption that Google didn't properly consider and test this change is likely wrong.)
Nov
8
revised Is there any justification for different behavior of different ways of triggering the same action?
added 1 character in body
Nov
8
revised Is there any justification for different behavior of different ways of triggering the same action?
added 239 characters in body
Nov
8
asked Is there any justification for different behavior of different ways of triggering the same action?
Nov
8
comment Do material design's floating action buttons provide a bad UX?
Another potential issue with the button there is that it is close to the phone's back button. I have often accidentally closed GMail when trying to press the (non-floating but in the same location) check mail button.
Nov
7
comment Best experience for copying tabs from multiple document types?
I don't think there is enough detail here, in both what you are trying to do and how the illustrated interface would work.
Nov
7
comment Mobile UX. To preview or not to preview before “Save”
But what does "preview" give when it is text-only content? What will they see by previewing that they can't see while editing it?