Take the 2-minute tour ×
User Experience Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for user experience researchers and experts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In my opinion, this button is very useful, giving you an ability to start over in just one click. But I can't seem to find non - Apple software that implements this pattern. Why?

EDIT: I'm not talking about web forms with multiple fields, these are a separate thing. One example is a browser - hit Ctrl-F, type something - now you have to hit backspace several times or Ctrl-A. Safari has the "clear input" button, but neither IE, FF or Chrome does.

Clear function in Safari

Clear function in Safari

It becomes worse if you use on-screen keyboard, since you can't use Ctrl-A.

share|improve this question
    
Is this what you mean imgur.com/VqMfr –  jonshariat Apr 26 '11 at 23:05
    
@jonshariat - yep! –  Sergey Aldoukhov Apr 26 '11 at 23:19

7 Answers 7

up vote 1 down vote accepted

It provides a clear way to delete text for users who are not accustomed to keyboard shortcuts to select all text in an input field. Additionally, assuming the value of the search input is not erased after a search has been carried out, it can potentially provide the fastest way to perform a new search for the non-power user demographic.

For example, on Firefox, when you return to the search box, it automatically selects the previously searched input meaning I can start typing the new search input immediately. However, for someone such as my mother who will reluctantly step through an operation on a computer, this may result in her first pressing Delete/Backspace before typing their new search as they perceive that to be a safer and more predictable route towards achieving their goal.

Alternatively, if a clear button was available, by being pressed first it deletes the existing search input and causes focus to be retained for the input resulting in the search being carried immediately in two steps as opposed to three.

Best case scenario for each method is the second search takes the same amount of steps to be carried out, but there does exist a possibility by not providing a clear action that a redundant step may be carried out by less experienced/confident users.

share|improve this answer

I commonly see "Reset Form" buttons, especially on old websites. I have never found these buttons to be useful.

If I want to start over, it's easy to just tab through the form fields (which selects all of the content in each one) and overwrite what was there before.

I have also come across many users who click it on accident when trying to submit in a hurry. If you do decide to use one, make sure it's far away from the submit button.

share|improve this answer
1  
Agree they aren't that useful... also they are very tiny and for many users are a pain to click on. –  TM. Apr 27 '11 at 4:18
    

I believe that a clear button is helpful on desktop applications and a necessity on mobile applications.

The reason that others don't use it is because they are all moving toward a minimalistic UI approach where they remove or group anything they can. A clear button is extra because it does not get used often.

share|improve this answer

I agree with Jonshariat. I have an iPad and I find that selecting text can be finicky and frustrating, so in my opinion the clear button is absolutely essential. Even though designers are gravitating to a minimalistic UI design, I don't believe that this simple addition would hinder, or distract a user, or take away from a minimalist design. It feels like it should be a standard addition to any browser.

share|improve this answer

I believe Opera does by default (HTML5 search field). FYI, Apple does not do this in mobile safari for some silly reason.

And there are sites that do this via JS...such as Google.

As more browsers support HTML5 and Webkit updates their UI a bit more for HTML5 fields, we'll probably see this more often as a default behavior of a search field.

share|improve this answer

Many web browsers select all by default when you tab to a field or click on it, so any typing will 'clear all'. The clear-all button is really only needed for the Mac behavior of moving the cursor to the click point, rather than selecting the field.

share|improve this answer

I think its clearly established that its required on a touchscreen (especially small touch screen) UI.

One good reason not to have this on the desktop is because the time taken to move your hand to the mouse and then move the mouse to the button is far more than the time taken to press ctrl + a + del/backspace.

share|improve this answer
    
I agree, though I'm still amazed at how many people reach for the mouse when they could just press ENTER (e.g. in a search box) or other simple keyboard operations like that. –  MetalMikester Jan 20 '12 at 13:06

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.