Take the 2-minute tour ×
User Experience Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for user experience researchers and experts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I was using my IE 10 when I right-clicked a link and its context menu showed up, I saw the first option was "Open Link". First thing that came to my mind was "What a useless option!". Since if I would simply open the link, I would click with left button.

I realized that this option comes from early IE versions, like version 6 - as far I can remember. Important to say that no other (major)browser have that option on context menu.

The question is: Why they keep that option for so long? Is it possible to have a meaning to that?

share|improve this question
1  
Fact: Opera 12.16 (Which I am using right now) as 5 'open' options on the right-click menu. Open in New and Backgroud Tab, Open in New and Backgroud Window, and a plain simple Open. Opinion: Maybe the plain simple 'open' is there for completion, so that if we eventually decide a "special" open is not what we needed, then we do not have to go back –  Rolazaro Azeveires Mar 26 at 21:26
    
Firefox has at least 3 versions of Open Link on its context menu. More if you have extensions installed that adjust the context menu. Chrome also has at least 2 versions of Open Link on its context menu as well. –  Adam Zuckerman Mar 27 at 5:28
    
@RolazaroAzeveires I thought this possibility too. –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 27 at 11:28
    
@AdamZuckerman maybe I was not clear enought. I mean the option "Open Link" only, not those that opens in new tab or whatever. –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 27 at 11:29
    
What if your left mouse button was broken...? At least you could still access by right mouse click menu and keyboard. –  zigojacko Mar 27 at 11:29

4 Answers 4

up vote 1 down vote accepted

A link is an element of certain documents, but not only web pages.

The system has a record of applications and actions associated with elements, like open, copy, move, share, extract, etc. The associated action depends on the element and the applications that are registered as capable to interact with it.

A link, which may appear on many applications, has the action "open", which can be accomplished by different programs, so having the option on the context menu is a logical behaviour of the system. It is just the main action for that element and it would be associated with one application, which may not be Internet Explorer.

share|improve this answer
    
You're right. Even a Windows' folder has "Open" option on its context menu. So you think that the browser who removed this option might been braking an *concept*(idk if is the right word)? Anyway, Chorme is known for this concept cahnges. It set aside the title bar... –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 27 at 11:39

I guess it is just related to the fact that a person might want to see all options he or she might have concerning that specific link.

Although useless at first, if the person has opened the options list clicking with the right mouse button, the option that this person finds to be the chosen one might be open link after all.

share|improve this answer
    
I think I got it. User probably won't miss an option to open link... –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 27 at 11:41

Interesting question - I have right-clicked a link thousands of times and yet I'm not sure I have ever registered the first option is simply "Open".

Regardless of the "logic" for including it, I would have thought the real question is: do people actually use it?

Personally I have never once selected that option. Even when I right-click and then decide I simply want to open the link, my natural behavior is just to move back to any of the link still visible by the menu and click it.

share|improve this answer
    
Actually, you know that option, but you probably in someway ignored it and forgot it. –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 27 at 11:33
    
Not sure what you mean. I've never noticed it before. Reading past something then instantly discarding it and never remembering it can't really be described as knowing something. –  Raff3000 Mar 27 at 11:48
    
Exactly what I tried to say. –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 27 at 12:08

Not everything is UX/UI design, sometimes it's technical/legacy choice.

Your navigation with left click and your right click are 2 different things. The right menu is populate with all available options from a the object under the mouse. This list of actions contains browser actions, browser extension actions, system actions, antivirus actions... this list could be filtered for security reason etc. When you choose some action in that popup the browser (navigation part) is not forced to be aware or to understand that choice, it only transmit the information to rightful application.
This list of action is available to programmers. If you try to do an application based on IE, you could find which object propose the action to open link and which don't. A screen reader for example could find what images are simple images and which link to another pages.

So my guess is that this legacy option is there for compatibility reasons as IE is used for long times some applications/automation process depends of this open link menu availability.

share|improve this answer
    
Now I got it. Most of the answers explain something like what you have wrote, with differente opinions and details. I used useless word but when I asked I expected that somebody give me a useful/practical meaning for that. –  DontVoteMeDown Mar 28 at 10:59

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.