Take the 2-minute tour ×
User Experience Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for user experience researchers and experts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am facing a hard time having design decision for below case. I am creating wireframe for a patient app. The platform is windows phone and surface (tablet). The nurse (user) needs to prescribe medications for patients. It can be taken at different times during the day also before or after meal. In order to depict this I have designed following wireframe.

Which of the below option is the perfect choice? (If no, whats the other options?) Appreciate pros and cons for the designs provided.

Note: The nurse also has the option to edit the medication and can view the app from different devices (win phone or surface only)

enter image description here

share|improve this question
3  
I would avoid B. From what I have seen from health care professionals, they first decide which medication to prescribe, and after that how to space it for the day. They don't go around thinking "what does the patient need after breakfast? a Loremepsom is good. And after dinner? Metformin. Oh, and another capsule of Lorempsom." It is more of a "The patient has X, so we will give Lorempsom for that. How much? 1200 mg per day should be enough. The serum levels will be high enough if we make it twice daily. And it irritates the stomach, so make it after food". But check my assumption with users. –  Rumi P. Jan 29 at 13:36
    
Great point @RumiP. but then this option B seems good solution for Patient app .. where patient will be able to see daily dosages (as per their mental model) but then with same app, different viewers (users or lets say persona) are viewing same information in different format (information grouping).. so will this hamper consistency? –  Spicerjet Jan 30 at 9:03

1 Answer 1

For option A, my brain has a hard time making sense of the information because the check boxes group together in a confusing way (gestalt laws of grouping). enter image description here

For option B, I agree with Rumi P.

Option C seems to be the best, but I can't help thinking it is missing some information. Especially for a grid that is editable, I would imagine there should be some sort of totals column for the total dosage of each medication type. In all your examples, a check in the wrong box might not be noticed by the user entering it, but the information could be blindly followed resulting in a medical mistake. In this use case some form of double checking is necessary. "Why does it say 5 times a day for this med? Oh, I meant to click the other box!"

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.