You can view the file here: http://www.cameron.thejoosebox.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/new.png (its a 1.8M file, will take a second to load).
I'm just looking for general impressions and some feedback on which one you think is easier to use, and which one you think people are more likely to engage with.
They're both the same from the top to the large featured image. I'm mostly concerned with the 3 columns' (or boxes) and the main body content and layout. The 3 boxes under the image on the left side design, may provide some "ins" to other content like services etc., which could be valuable. That also means the contact form, testimonials, and contact info is put in a sidebar in the main content area; and maybe that info is more valuable under the image, as seen on the right hand design. The right hand design is quite a bit less content (even though its the same length), which I think may provide a better UX than the dense content on the left.